Gas boilers are on their way out, and more households across London, the South East, the South West and South Wales are deciding which low carbon heating system should replace them. The two options that come up most often are electric boilers and air source heat pumps. Both run on electricity, both produce zero emissions inside your home, and both can heat your radiators and hot water. That is roughly where the similarities end.
The real difference in the electric boiler vs heat pump decision comes down to efficiency. An electric boiler turns 1 unit of electricity into about 1 unit of heat. A well installed air source heat pump turns that same unit into around 3 units of heat by pulling free warmth out of the outside air. With electricity costing roughly four times more per unit than mains gas, that gap shows up on every single bill.
In this guide, our team at EE Renewables compares the two systems on upfront costs, running costs, efficiency, reliability, grants and the types of property each one suits. We have written it for homeowners and landlords who want straight answers, using current UK figures and what we see every week installing heat pumps across Southern England and South Wales.
Heat pumps generally cost more to install than electric boilers but can offer significantly lower running costs over time. Electric boilers are usually cheaper and simpler to install, although their higher electricity consumption can make them more expensive to run. The table below compares both heating systems across the factors that matter most to UK homeowners and landlords.
| Factor | Electric Boiler | Air Source Heat Pump |
|---|---|---|
| Energy efficiency | Around 99% (1 kWh in, about 1 kWh of heat out) | 250% to 400% (1 kWh in, about 2.5 to 4 kWh of heat out) |
| Heating performance | Fast, hot radiators, but output limited by your electricity supply | Steady, gentle warmth at lower temperatures, works down to about minus 20°C |
| Installation costs | Roughly £2,000 to £5,000 fitted | Roughly £10,000 to £15,000 before grants, often £3,000 to £7,000 after the grant |
| Running costs (typical home) | Around £2,900 to £3,100 a year | Around £950 to £1,100 a year, less on a heat pump tariff |
| Grants and funding | No national grant | £7,500 Boiler Upgrade Scheme grant in England and Wales, plus 0% VAT |
| Reliability and lifespan | Few moving parts, typically lasts 10 to 15 years | Proven technology, typically lasts 15 to 20 years or more |
| Servicing and maintenance | Minimal, occasional electrical checks | Annual service recommended, around £100 to £200 |
| Noise | Virtually silent | Outdoor unit hums quietly, similar to a fridge at close range |
| Space requirements | Compact wall unit, plus a hot water cylinder for most setups | Outdoor unit, plus an indoor hot water cylinder |
| Properties best suited to | Small flats, low heat demand, no outdoor space | Most houses, bungalows and many flats with outdoor space |
| Carbon emissions | Zero on site, but uses about 3 times more electricity | Zero on site, roughly a third of the emissions of an electric boiler |
| EPC rating impact | Often lowers or holds back the EPC score | Usually improves the EPC score |
| Landlord considerations | No annual gas safety certificate needed, but high bills for tenants | No gas safety certificate needed, lower bills help with EPC rules |
Running cost figures assume a typical home needing about 11,500 kWh of heat a year and electricity at around 26p per kWh, close to the Ofgem price cap level through 2025 and 2026. Your own figures will depend on your home, your insulation and your tariff.
Thinking about making the switch? EE Renewables provides expert air source heat pump installation across Southern England, Greater London, South West England and South Wales, including areas like London, Brighton, Oxford, Southampton, Bristol and Cardiff. Get in touch today for a free air source heat pump quote tailored to your location.
The right choice depends on your home’s heating requirements, how long you plan to stay in the property and whether you have suitable outdoor space for a heat pump. For many homes, a heat pump can offer better long-term value through lower running costs, while an electric boiler may be more practical for smaller properties, homes with limited outdoor space or those with lower heating demands.
Electric boilers and heat pumps have different advantages and drawbacks, particularly when it comes to installation costs and long-term running expenses. Heat pumps require a larger upfront investment and more planning, but can offer lower running costs.
Electric boilers are generally cheaper and simpler to install, although they can cost more to run. Here’s a balanced look at the pros and cons of each.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Around 3 times more efficient than an electric boiler | Higher upfront cost before the grant |
| Running costs roughly a third of an electric boiler’s | Needs outdoor space for the unit |
| £7,500 Boiler Upgrade Scheme grant available | Works best with decent insulation |
| 0% VAT on installation until March 2027 | Radiators feel warm rather than very hot |
| Long lifespan of 15 to 20 years or more | Annual servicing recommended |
| Usually improves your EPC rating | Installation takes a few days |
| Lowest carbon way to heat most homes | Outdoor unit makes a low hum |
| Can provide cooling with some models | Needs a hot water cylinder |
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Low upfront cost, often under £5,000 fitted | Very high running costs |
| Compact and fits almost anywhere | No national grant available |
| Virtually silent | Shorter lifespan of 10 to 15 years |
| No outdoor unit or flue needed | Output limited by your electricity supply |
| Very little maintenance | Can drag down your EPC rating |
| Quick to install, often in a day | Uses about 3 times more electricity than a heat pump |
| No gas safety certificate needed | Most models still need a hot water cylinder |
| Good for very small, low demand flats | Struggles to heat larger homes affordably |
The following sections explore each factor from our quick comparison table in more detail, from installation costs and running expenses to efficiency and maintenance. Each section also highlights which system comes out ahead, making it easier to see how electric boilers and heat pumps compare.
Energy efficiency is the biggest difference between the two systems. An electric boiler converts almost all the electricity it uses into heat, giving it an efficiency of around 99%. That sounds impressive, but it can never produce more heat than the electricity you pay for.
An air source heat pump works differently. It uses electricity to move heat from the outside air into your home, rather than creating heat directly. This is measured by the Seasonal Coefficient of Performance (SCOP).
Most modern heat pumps achieve a SCOP of 3 to 4 in lab conditions, and real UK homes typically see around 2.8 to 3.5 over a full year. The government backed Electrification of Heat trial, run by Energy Systems Catapult, recorded a median of around 2.8 across a wide mix of homes, with the best installations doing far better.
In plain terms, for every £1 of electricity, a heat pump delivers around £3 of heat. An electric boiler delivers £1.
Winner: Heat pump
Heating performance from an electric boiler feels much like a gas boiler. Radiators get hot quickly and you can heat a room fast. The catch is output. A typical home on a single phase supply can usually only support an electric boiler of up to about 12 to 15 kW, which may not be enough for a larger or draughty house on a cold day.
Heat pumps run at lower temperatures, usually 35°C to 50°C at the radiators, and keep the house at a steady temperature rather than blasting heat in short bursts. Modern models keep working in temperatures as low as minus 20°C, which is well beyond anything Southern England or South Wales normally sees.
Our milder coastal climate in places like Brighton, Southampton, Bristol and Cardiff actually helps heat pumps run more efficiently.
If you like to switch the heating on and feel it instantly, an electric boiler responds faster. For comfortable, even warmth all day, a heat pump is better.
Winner: Heat pump (for whole home comfort)
Installation costs are where electric boilers win clearly. A fitted electric boiler usually costs around £2,000 to £5,000, depending on the size, whether you need a new hot water cylinder, and any electrical upgrades. Fitting often takes a day or two.
| Installation Cost Factor | Electric Boiler | Air Source Heat Pump |
|---|---|---|
| Typical installed cost before grants | £2,000 to £5,000 | £10,000 to £15,000 |
| Government grant | None | £7,500 Boiler Upgrade Scheme grant |
| Typical cost after grants | £2,000 to £5,000 | £3,000 to £7,000 |
| What is usually included | Boiler, any new hot water cylinder, electrical upgrades | Outdoor unit, hot water cylinder, controls, often some radiator upgrades |
| Typical fitting time | One to two days | Two to five days |
An air source heat pump typically costs £10,000 to £15,000 before grants for an average home. That price includes the outdoor unit, a hot water cylinder, controls and often some radiator upgrades. Once you take off the £7,500 Boiler Upgrade Scheme grant, many of our customers pay somewhere between £3,000 and £7,000, which is often close to the price of a new oil or gas boiler.
Winner: Electric boiler
Running costs are where a heat pump earns back its higher price tag. Electricity costs roughly 26p per kWh at current price cap levels, compared with roughly 6p to 7p for mains gas. That makes any electric heating expensive unless it is very efficient.
Take a typical home needing about 11,500 kWh of heat a year:
| Running Cost Factor | Electric Boiler | Air Source Heat Pump |
|---|---|---|
| Heat needed per year (typical home) | 11,500 kWh | 11,500 kWh |
| Efficiency | Around 99% | Around 300% (SCOP of 3) |
| Electricity used per year | Around 11,600 kWh | Around 3,800 kWh |
| Electricity price | Around 26p per kWh | Around 26p per kWh |
| Estimated annual running cost | Around £3,000 | Around £1,000 |
| Estimated annual saving | None | Around £2,000 |
| Estimated running cost over 10 years | Around £30,000 | Around £10,000 |
| Cheaper tariff options | Economy 7 with a storage electric boiler | Heat pump tariffs from suppliers such as Octopus Energy, OVO and E.ON Next |
That is a saving of about £2,000 every year. Specialist heat pump tariffs from suppliers such as Octopus Energy, OVO and E.ON Next offer cheaper rates at certain times of day, which can cut heat pump running costs further. Electric boiler owners can use Economy 7 with a storage electric boiler, but they still need about three times as many units of electricity.
Winner: Heat pump
Grants and funding strongly favour heat pumps. The Boiler Upgrade Scheme gives £7,500 towards an air source heat pump in England and Wales, as long as it is installed by an MCS certified installer. Heat pump installations also benefit from 0% VAT until March 2027.
Electric boilers are not eligible for the Boiler Upgrade Scheme. Some local council or ECO4 schemes may help low income households with heating upgrades, but there is no national grant for electric boilers. Homeowners in Wales on lower incomes may also be able to get support through the Welsh Government’s Nest scheme, which favours efficient heating like heat pumps.
Winner: Heat pump
Reliability is good for both systems. Electric boilers have very few moving parts, so breakdowns are rare. They typically last 10 to 15 years, with heating elements and pumps being the parts most likely to need replacing.
Heat pumps are proven technology that has been used across Scandinavia for decades, even in harsh winters. A good quality unit from manufacturers such as Mitsubishi Electric, Daikin, Vaillant or Samsung typically lasts 15 to 20 years or more, and many come with manufacturer warranties of 7 to 10 years when installed and registered correctly.
Winner: Heat pump (longer lifespan)
Servicing and maintenance needs are lower for an electric boiler. There is no combustion, no flue and no annual gas safety check. An occasional check by an electrician is usually all that is needed.
Heat pumps should be serviced once a year, which typically costs £100 to £200. A service checks refrigerant pressure, cleans filters and makes sure the system is running efficiently. Most manufacturers require annual servicing to keep the warranty valid. Day to day, all you need to do is keep leaves and debris away from the outdoor unit.
Winner: Electric boiler
Noise is not an issue with an electric boiler, which is almost silent indoors. Heat pumps have an outdoor fan and compressor that produce a low hum, usually around 40 to 60 decibels when you stand close to the unit. That is roughly the level of a fridge or a quiet conversation, and much quieter from inside the house. Installers must follow MCS noise rules to protect neighbours, which matters in densely built areas such as London terraces.
Winner: Electric boiler
Space requirements are smaller for an electric boiler. The unit itself is about the size of a kitchen cupboard and mounts on a wall. Most systems still need a hot water cylinder, unless you choose an electric combi model with limited hot water flow.
A heat pump needs an outdoor unit, roughly the size of a large suitcase, fitted on the ground or a wall bracket. Indoors, you will need space for a hot water cylinder, often in an airing cupboard or loft. Homes that already have a cylinder usually find the switch straightforward.
Winner: Electric boiler
The properties best suited to an electric boiler are small flats and studios with very low heat demand, particularly where there is no outdoor space or the building rules out an external unit. You will see these a lot in central London blocks.
Heat pumps suit the vast majority of UK homes. The Electrification of Heat trial found that no single type or age of home was unsuitable, from Victorian terraces to 1960s semis and modern new builds.
Detached and semi detached houses in Oxford, Bristol or the Hampshire countryside, coastal bungalows in Sussex and Devon, and family homes in Cardiff and the Vale of Glamorgan are all excellent candidates. Homes off the gas grid, roughly 4 million across Great Britain, often save the most when replacing oil or LPG.
Winner: Heat pump (suits far more homes)
Carbon emissions from both systems are zero at your home, because neither burns fuel. The difference is in how much electricity each one uses. Because a heat pump needs around a third of the electricity of an electric boiler for the same heat, it also produces around a third of the carbon emissions at the power station. As the UK grid gets greener each year, both systems get cleaner, but the heat pump always stays ahead.
Winner: Heat pump
EPC rating impact can surprise people. Energy Performance Certificates are based largely on estimated running costs, so an electric boiler’s high bills often lower a home’s rating or stop it improving, even though it is low carbon.
A heat pump usually lifts the EPC score, often by one band or more, especially when paired with good insulation or solar panels. A better EPC can make a home more attractive to buyers and can help with green mortgage deals from lenders such as Nationwide, NatWest and Barclays.
Winner: Heat pump
Landlord considerations matter more than ever. Rental homes in England and Wales must currently meet at least EPC band E, and the government has set out plans for privately rented homes in England to reach band C by 2030. Neither an electric boiler nor a heat pump needs an annual gas safety certificate, which removes one compliance task. Landlords still need a valid electrical safety report (EICR) at least every five years.
The problem with an electric boiler in a rental is the bill your tenants face and the effect on your EPC. A heat pump keeps bills lower, which helps reduce arrears and void periods, and gives you the best chance of meeting future EPC targets. Landlords can also claim the Boiler Upgrade Scheme grant.
Winner: Heat pump
Getting a free air source heat pump quote from EE Renewables is quick, simple and comes with no obligation. As the leading air source heat pump installation specialist across Southern England, we help homeowners and landlords swap expensive heating for a system that costs less to run, lasts longer and adds value to their property.
When you get in touch, our team will:
Request your free air source heat pump quote today and find out how much you could save compared with an electric boiler.
We cover Greater London, Southern England, South West England and South Wales, including London, Brighton, Oxford, Southampton, Bristol, Cardiff and the towns and villages around them. Whether you own a Victorian terrace in Clapham, a family home in Oxfordshire or a rental portfolio across Bristol and Bath, we can help.
No, neither an electric boiler nor a heat pump will work during a power cut, because both need electricity to run. A well insulated home loses heat slowly, so it usually stays comfortable for several hours. Homes with a home battery can keep some systems running for a short time.
You may need to replace some radiators to get a heat pump, but rarely all of them. Heat pumps run at lower water temperatures, so a few rooms may need slightly larger radiators to stay warm. Your installer works this out room by room during a heat loss survey, and the cost is normally included in your quote.
Yes, solar panels can help power both an electric boiler and a heat pump, but they make a much bigger difference with a heat pump. Because a heat pump turns each unit of electricity into around three units of heat, every kWh your panels generate goes about three times further. Adding a battery lets you store daytime solar for evening heating.
Most homes in England and Wales do not need planning permission for an air source heat pump, because installations usually fall under permitted development rights. The unit must meet MCS noise limits and size and position rules. Listed buildings, some flats and certain conservation area properties may need permission, so your installer should check before work starts.
A heat pump installation usually takes two to five days, while an electric boiler can often be fitted in one or two days. Heat pumps take longer because they involve an outdoor unit, a new hot water cylinder and sometimes radiator changes. Most households keep hot water and some heating for most of the installation.